Can Hockey Goalies Get Penalties? (Of Course)

Posted on February 6, 2020 by Dan Kent
hockey goalie

Hockey goalies are subject to the same rules as all other players on the ice but they do get unique and special treatment in some areas of the game. The main difference between goalies and other skaters regards the serving of penalties during games and this applies to most hockey leagues and organizations. So what’s the deal can netminders get penalties? and how come you never see goalies sitting in the penalty box?

Like all other players, hockey goalies can and do get penalties in the heat of the action. However, they don’t have to leave the ice to serve the infraction as a teammate is allowed to sit in the penalty box for them. Goalies do have to leave the game though if they’re ejected from the contest for any reason including earning three major penalties. Therefore any two, five and 10 minute penalties incurred by a goalie means they remain in net while a teammate who was on the ice at the time of the infraction serves the penalty. 

The National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) handles things a little differently as goalies are made to sit in the penalty box if they receive a five-minute major or 10-minute misconduct penalty. In this case, the backup goalie takes over in net. 

Rules Concerning Goaltenders’ Penalties

NHL: Goalie Penalties

NHL goaltenders’ penalties are subject to NHL Rule 27. It states that if a goalie’s teammate receives a two-minute minor or five-minute major penalty on the same play as the goaltender they aren’t allowed to serve the netminder’s penalty.

The penalty minutes are charged to the goaltender though. In this instance, another teammate on the ice must also enter the penalty box in place of the goalkeeper.

The reason for this is because the team serving the penalties should be forced to play two players short for two minutes rather than one player short for four minutes. 

If an organized professional or amateur league goaltender receives a game misconduct or match penalty they must leave the contest and are also subject to any financial fines and further league discipline. 

Penalties Unique to Goaltenders

Goaltenders can be assessed the same penalties as other players including, tripping, hooking, slashing, interference and fighting etc. In addition, there are also several infractions that are unique to goalies. 

Here are some examples:

  1. If a goalie leaves the goal crease during an on-ice altercation it can result in a minor penalty. If the goalie is already outside of the crease for some reason when an altercation between other players takes place then no penalty is given. 
  2. If a goalie heads to the players’ bench during a stoppage of play without the permission of a referee it results in a minor penalty for delay of game or the backup goalie must enter the net. 
  3. Goaltenders who play the puck or check an opponent on the offensive side of the center red line shall be penalized two minutes if the puck is over the red line.
  4. A netminder can’t play the puck if it’s in the sectioned off areas of the ice surface in the corners of the rink behind the goal line. This is know as the ‘trapezoid zone‘ and it means goalies can’t leave their net to handle the puck in this area as it will result in a delay of game penalty.
  5. Equipment specification: Goaltenders must also abide by specific NHL rules concerning the size of their sticks and equipment.
  6. On the bright side, a goalie is the only player on the ice who is allowed to play with a broken stick. However, a minor penalty is assessed if a goalie places a broken stick in front of the goal line of the net at any time during a game.
  7. A goalie can’t skate to the player’s bench to receive a new stick to replace a broken one while play is going on without receiving a minor penalty. A teammate must give the goalie a new stick.  
goalie penalty

Goalies used to Served their own Penalties

Goaltenders in the NHL used to serve their own penalties up until the 1941/42 season. When assessed a penalty the goalie would sit in the penalty box while another position player would protect the goal with the use of a goalie stick. 

When the 1939/40 season arrived, players who stood in the crease while the goalie served a penalty were allowed to wear the goaltender’s gloves and use a goalie stick. 

Top 5 Dirtiest Goalie Slashes of All Time | NHL

The NHL and most other hockey leagues and organizations across the globe introduce new rules on a regular basis. But one rule that isn’t likely to change is the one concerning goaltenders serving their own minor penalties. 

We may see goalies eventually being forced to serve their own major and misconduct penalties like they do in the NCAA, However, having netminders serve their own two-minute infractions would simply take up too much time while the backup goalie gets ready to take over. 

Want to learn more about netminders, see why they have a pre-game ritual of scraping the ice in their crease?

Can Hockey Goalies Fight?

Yes, goalies fight, but it is rare. The main reason they do not fight as often is to avoid injury and as they are not at the center of most play or confrontations.

I cover this and much more in the main article on this topic: Why Hockey Goalies Fight

Dan Kent

About the author

Growing up in a hockey hotbed (Calgary, Alberta. And yes, I'm an Oiler fan), I decided to put my love and knowledge of the game to work. I started at five and am still playing today into my early 30s. By acquiring Brave Stick Hockey and rebranding it to Big Shot Hockey in 2023, I plan to teach people about this great game and educate them on the best equipment and history of the game. On a career level, I am in finance, running one of the largest financial websites in Canada,

Looking for more hockey content? Have a look at these articles